Skip to main content

Amanda Knox Conviction Lacked Evidence, Italian Court Says



Amanda Knox Conviction Lacked Evidence, Italian Court Says

Italy’s top criminal court said the case against Amanda Knox and her Italian boyfriend lack evidence and contained “stunning flaws.”
Ted S. Warren / AP

Italy’s top criminal court on Monday threw out a 2009 murder conviction against Amanda Knox and her former Italian boyfriend for the death of her British roommate, saying prosecutors presented a flawed case and there was no “biological traces” to connect them to the crime.
The Court of Cassation in Rome issued its formal written explanation for its March ruling, which had vindicated Knox and her former boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito for the 2007 murder of 21-year-old Meredith Kercher, who was brutally stabbed in the apartment the two woman had shared while studying abroad in Perugia, Italy.
Raffaele Sollecito Andrew Medichini / AP
On Monday, the 52-page explanation outlined the court’s reasoning for the acquittal of Knox and Sollecito, who have maintained their innocence throughout, saying there were no biological traces in the room where Kercher was killed to connect them.
“There was no shortage of glaring errors in the underlying fabric of the sentence in question,” the court wrote, citing the prosecution’s flawed case from the start.
Media attention also played a factor in hindering the case, the high court said, because investigators were under pressure to produce results.
“The international spotlight on the case in fact resulted in the investigation undergoing a sudden acceleration,” the judges wrote.
Knox, who is now 28, and Sollecito, 31, both spent nearly four years in Italian prison after a lower court in Perugia convicted them of murder in 2009. They were acquitted after a first appeals court trial, but were convicted again by a court in Florence in a 2014 ruling, which sentenced Knox to almost 29 years in jail — assuming she would have been extradited from the U.S. — and Sollecito to 25 years.
Rudy Hermann Guede Pier Paolo Cito / AP
In separate proceedings, Rudy Hermann Guede from the Ivory Coast was convicted of the murder and is currently serving a 16-year sentence. He left “copious” biological traces, the court said in its 52-page memo.
The court said it was possible that Guede had accomplices, but nothing proved that Knox or Collecito were involved. They criticized prosecutors for the motive they presented — that Knox had been resentful of her roommate — while providing little evidence to back it up.
The memo criticized lower court judges for ignoring expert testimony that “clearly demonstrated possible contamination” of evidence and misinterpreted findings about the knife allegedly used to kill Kercher. No traces of blood were found on the knife, they wrote.
The idea that Knox and Sollecito had cleaned the crime scene, wiping away their DNA, was also ruled as impossible, the court said.
The court also said investigators were incompetent. For example, computers owned by Knox and Kercher that may have provided information in the case were “burned by imprudent maneuvers by the investigators, who caused an electric shock.”
A bra clasp which supposedly carried DNA evidence that linked Sollecito to the murder scene was left on the floor for 46 days and then was handled by investigators who wore “dirty latex gloves,” the court said.
The supposed time of death, as argued by prosecutors, was also a “deplorable approximation,” they wrote.
Pier Paolo Cito / AP
“She is very satisfied and happy to read this decision,” a lawyer for Knox, Carlo Dalla Vedova, told the Associated Press. “At the same time, it’s a very sad story. It’s a sad story because Meredith Kercher is no longer with us, and this is a tragedy nobody can forget.”
Kercher’s family expressed dismay in March when Knox and Sollecito were acquitted, the Guardian reported.
The court’s ruling on Monday, however, did leave some questions open, such as whether Knox and Sollecito might have been in another room in the apartment at the time Kercher was killed.
Diya “Patrick” Lumumba Riccardo De Luca / AP
The court also said it remained unknown why Knox identified an African man as the suspect when later a different man was convicted.
The court said Knox deserved her almost four-year jail sentence for slandering her boss, Diya “Patrick Lumumba, a Congolese-born bar owner who she accused of the crime. Lumumba was in jail for two weeks until an alibi led to his release.
The judges’ decision ruled out the possibility of another trial, saying it would have been useless.
Michelle Broder Van Dyke is a reporter and night editor for BuzzFeed News and is based in Hawaii.
Contact Michelle Broder Van Dyke at michelle@buzzfeed.com.

Popular posts from this blog

Hidden Wiki

Welcome to The Hidden WikiNew hidden wiki url 2015 http://zqktlwi4fecvo6ri.onion Add it to bookmarks and spread it!!!
Editor's picks Bored? Pick a random page from the article index and replace one of these slots with it.
The Matrix - Very nice to read. How to Exit the Matrix - Learn how to Protect yourself and your rights, online and off. Verifying PGP signatures - A short and simple how-to guide. In Praise Of Hawala - Anonymous informal value transfer system. Volunteer Here are five different things that you can help us out with.
Plunder other hidden service lists for links and place them here! File the SnapBBSIndex links wherever they go. Set external links to HTTPS where available, good certificate, and same content. Care to start recording onionland's history? Check out Onionland's Museum Perform Dead Services Duties. Introduction PointsAhmia.fi - Clearnet search engine for Tor Hidden Services (allows you to add new sites to its database). DuckDuckGo - A Hidden S…

[SOLVED] IDM WAS REGISTERED WITH A FAKE SERIAL NUMBER

[SOLVED] IDM WAS REGISTERED WITH A FAKE SERIAL NUMBER
Good News [May 08, 2015]: IDM developers got smarter, but the crackers are always a step ahead. Follow this article and send an email to uglyduckblog@gmail.com if you are desperate. I can NOT post any crack here for legal reasons. Happy Downloading with IDM. ;) *********** first tip is to use latest crack for idm from  onhax.net idm universal web crack and make sure u are using all latest vers I am sure many of us are too much dependent on Internet Download Manager a.k.a. IDM. The main reason didn’t permanently switch to linux was IDM. I mainly use it for batch downloading and download streaming videos. Till yesterday, IDM was working fine with me (of course with fake serial numbers, keygen, crack, patch etc. which could be found with little effort). But few days ago, with the latest update version 6.18 build 7 (released on Nov 09, 2013) Internet Download Manager was literally had a breakthrough and crushed all the serial numbers, …

Mouse, touchpad, and keyboard problems in Windows

Mouse, touchpad, and keyboard problems in Windows Introduction This tutorial is designed to help you identify and fix common mouse, touchpad, and keyboard problems in Windows. It doesn't cover device problems related to specific programs. Mouse, touchpad, and keyboard problems can have a number of causes: Cables that aren't connected properly Incorrect device settings Missing updates Corrupted or incompatible drivers Hardware problems Check hardware Many mouse, touchpad, and keyboard problems are caused by hardware that isn't set up properly. Here's some information about how to check your device, make sure cables are connected properly, make sure the hardware has power, and check the settings. Make sure cables are connected properly Check that all cables are plugged in to the correct locations. This can include mouse and keyboard, PS2 and USB cables, and, in some cases, external USB touchpad cables. Disconnect USB cables and wait for a short time for the device drive…